Michael Nolen of Atlantic Shore Sotheby's International Realty

Subscribe to Email Updates

Select Topics

Latest Blog Post

5 Pro Tips: Buying Ocean City MD Vacation Rentals Like Smart Investors

Michael Nolen
by Michael Nolen on September 8, 2026 at 4:55 PM

Buying a vacation rental property isn’t just about finding a great condo at the beach and asking, “How much will it rent for?”

Smart vacation rental investing starts with understanding your goals, studying the market, knowing the true costs, and finding opportunities to outperform the competition.

I’ve worked with vacation rental properties from several sides—as a real estate professional, investor, owner, host, and property manager. One thing I’ve learned is that there isn’t one definition of a successful vacation rental investment.

That’s especially true in the Ocean City, MD real estate market, where a property can be an investment, vacation home, income-producing asset, and long-term real estate hold all at the same time.

Here are five areas I recommend researching before buying an Ocean City, MD vacation rental property.

 

Pro Tips - Buying OC Vacation Rentals Smart Investor Blog

 


PRO TIP #1: Establish Your Investment Goal & Target Rate of Return

What Type of Vacation Rental Investor Are You?

 

Before looking at rental projections, determine what you’re actually trying to accomplish.

Not every vacation rental investor is looking for the highest possible cash flow.

Some buyers want a specific return on their cash. Others are thinking about long-term appreciation. And many Ocean City buyers simply want a beach property they can enjoy while vacation rental income helps offset the cost of ownership.

Understanding which investor you are should come before deciding which property is right for you.

The Long-Term Investor

A long-term investor may be willing to accept a lower immediate return because the bigger goal is owning real estate over many years.

Rental income helps offset expenses while you’re building equity and holding an asset that has the potential to appreciate over time.

Your return isn’t based solely on rental income. You’re considering the combination of:

  • Rental income
  • Cost of ownership
  • Principal reduction
  • Personal use
  • Potential long-term appreciation

For this investor, the real estate itself is part of the investment strategy.

 

The Cash-Flow & ROI Investor

Other investors are much more numbers-driven.

If you’re putting $100,000, $200,000, or more into a property, how much money do you expect that investment to produce?

Gross rental income doesn’t answer that question.

You have to calculate the expenses associated with owning and operating the property—including financing, taxes, insurance, condo fees, utilities, management, maintenance, furnishings, marketing, and other vacation rental expenses.

Instead of only asking:

“How much does this property rent for?”
Ask:
“What is my actual return after the cost of owning and operating it?”

That’s a much more valuable number to consider!

 

The Ocean City, MD Vacation Rental Lifestyle & Personal Goal Investor

This may be the most common type of investor in a resort market like Ocean City.

You want a place at the beach.

You want to use it with your family.

And you’d like vacation rental income to help pay for it.

Maybe the property covers all of its expenses. Maybe it covers most of them. Maybe it produces additional income.

Your return includes something that doesn’t always show up on a spreadsheet: your ability to enjoy the property yourself.

If guests help pay the annual expenses while you get to enjoy your own Ocean City vacation home, that may represent an excellent investment for your goals.

 

Define Success Before You Shop

Before comparing properties, establish what success means to you.

Once you know your target, it becomes much easier to determine which properties deserve a closer look.

 


PRO TIP #2: Use Short-Term Rental Data to Understand the Market

Start With AirDNA

 

One resource vacation rental investors can use is AirDNA, which provides short-term rental market data for destinations such as Ocean City, Maryland.

Market-level numbers are useful—but don’t stop there.

 

Compare the Right Types of Property

Break down the available vacation rental inventory.

How many:
  • Efficiencies and studios are available?
  • One-bedroom rentals?
  • Two-bedroom rentals?
  • Three-bedroom rentals?
  • Four-bedroom rentals?
  • Five-bedroom-plus properties?

If you’re considering purchasing a three-bedroom Ocean City condo, comparing it against every vacation rental in the market isn’t necessarily helpful.

You want to understand the competitive set your property would actually face.

 

Study More Than Gross Rental Revenue

Look at metrics such as:
  • Average daily rate (ADR)
  • Occupancy
  • Estimated annual rental revenue
  • Available rental inventory
  • Seasonality
  • Revenue percentiles
  • Comparable property performance

This gives you a better understanding of where a potential property might fall within the Ocean City, Maryland short-term rental market.

Remember: Data Is a Starting Point

No rental projection should be treated as a guarantee.

Historical data tells you what has happened. It doesn’t automatically tell you what will happen.

Use the numbers as one part of a larger investment analysis.

 


PRO TIP #3: Research Vacation Rental Marketing Channels

Search Like a Vacationer on AirBnB, VRBO, Google & Beyond

 

Don’t only rely on reports and spreadsheets.

Go directly to where your future guests are shopping.

Research vacation rentals on Airbnb, VRBO, Booking .com, local vacation rental websites, and local property management or brokerage websites. Don't forget Google searching! Google will show you a lot of variations of how vacation renters search!

Then search like you’re planning your own vacation.

 

Study Your Direct Competition

If you’re considering a three-bedroom condo, search for comparable three-bedroom properties.

Look at:
  • Nightly and weekly rates
  • Minimum stays
  • Availability
  • Photography
  • Property descriptions
  • Amenities
  • Reviews
  • Promotions
  • Booking policies

Then repeat those searches throughout the year.

 

Fall Season in Ocean City, MD: Great Time to Start Your Research

The offseason is an important research period in Ocean City.

Not every property will immediately have its entire following summer calendar available. As owners and managers begin opening dates and establishing rates, you’ll start seeing more of the competitive landscape.

Watching that process over several months can give you a much better understanding than taking one snapshot of the market.

 

Understand Where Properties Are Being Advertised

Not every Ocean City vacation rental is marketed the same way.

Some properties may appear primarily through a local property management company or brokerage. Others may be distributed across Airbnb, Vrbo, local websites, and direct-booking channels.

That’s important when you’re analyzing historical rental performance.

A property that wasn’t marketed aggressively may have untapped potential.

 

Don’t Assume Past Performance Equals Future Potential

If you’re evaluating a property that produced a certain amount of rental income last year, ask how that income was generated.

Was it professionally photographed?

Was it listed across multiple channels?

Were rates adjusted throughout the season?

Was the listing optimized?

Were reviews strong?

Understanding how a property was managed and marketed can be just as important as knowing how much it rented for.

 


PRO TIP #4: Calculate the TRUE Local Cost of Vacation Rental Ownership

Purchase Price Is Only the Beginning

 

A property can generate impressive rental income and still be a poor investment if its expenses are too high.

Before buying an Ocean City vacation rental investment property, build a realistic annual cost-of-ownership estimate.

Know Your Fixed Expenses

Depending on the property, your annual costs may include:

  • Mortgage principal and interest
  • Property taxes
  • Condo or HOA fees
  • Insurance
  • Electric
  • Water and sewer
  • Internet and cable

These expenses exist whether you have a great rental season or a slow one.

 

Calculate Your Vacation Rental Operating Expenses

Then consider the costs specifically associated with operating the property as a vacation rental:

  • Property management
  • Cleaning
  • Maintenance
  • Repairs
  • Furnishings
  • Appliance replacement
  • Linens and supplies
  • Rental-related insurance
  • Marketing
  • Booking/channel costs

A realistic investment analysis needs to account for both property ownership and vacation rental operations.

 

Pay Attention to Property-Specific & Local Amenities

Every property is different.

Does it have a hot tub?

Pool?

Elevators?

Private parking?

Special amenities?

Who maintains them?

How much does that cost?

Is the expense included in your condo fee or paid separately?

 

Amenities can help a property stand out, but they can also create additional operating and maintenance expenses.

 

Understand How Management Handles Maintenance

If you’re planning to hire a vacation rental management company, ask detailed questions.

Who handles a broken air conditioner during a guest’s stay?

Who calls the contractor?

Who approves the repair?

Is there a markup?

Are there additional service fees?

Understanding these details before you buy can prevent expensive surprises later.

 


PRO TIP #5: Learn to Evaluate Rates Like an Experienced Investor

Don’t Just Ask What Competitors Charge

 

This is where vacation rental investing becomes more than simply analyzing numbers.

When I’m evaluating competition, I don’t only want to know:

“What are they charging?”

I also want to know:

“How could this property do it better?”

 

Look for Ways to Outperform the Competition

Study comparable listings and identify opportunities.
 
Could you provide:
  • Better professional photography?
  • Better staging?
  • A stronger listing description?
  • More desirable amenities?
  • Better guest communication?
  • Easier check-in?
  • Better mattresses and furnishings?
  • A more family-friendly experience?
  • A better overall presentation?

 

Small improvements can completely change how a guest perceives one property compared with another.

 

Read the Reviews—Especially the Negative Ones

Reviews are one of my favorite research tools.

Five-star reviews tell you what guests love.

Negative reviews tell you where opportunities exist.

If competing guests repeatedly complain about uncomfortable mattresses, outdated furnishings, poor kitchen supplies, cleanliness, confusing check-in instructions, weak Wi-Fi, or missing amenities, pay attention.

 

Turn Their Negatives Into Your Positives

Those complaints can become part of your investment strategy.

If you know what frustrates guests at competing properties, you have the opportunity to address those problems before your first guest ever arrives.

That’s one of the ways experienced investors begin separating themselves from the competition.

 

Think Like a Vacation Rental Traveler

Some of the best vacation rental investors use their own travel experiences.

When you stay in an Airbnb, Vrbo, hotel, or vacation rental, pay attention.

What impressed you?

What frustrated you?

What made the property memorable?

What would make you return?

Then apply those lessons to your own property.

 

Don’t Just Buy an Ocean City Vacation Rental—Build a Strategy

There are plenty of properties for sale in a resort market.

That doesn’t mean every property is a good vacation rental investment.

Know Your Numbers

Understand your expected return, ownership expenses, operating costs, and potential rental income.

Know Your Competition

Research comparable vacation rentals, their pricing, amenities, marketing, reviews, and booking channels.

Know Your Goal

Are you looking for cash flow?

Long-term appreciation?

A second home that helps pay for itself?

Or some combination of all three?

There isn’t one correct answer.

The smartest investment isn’t necessarily the property advertising the highest rental income.

It’s the property that best matches your financial goals, lifestyle, and long-term strategy.

 

Looking for an Ocean City, Maryland Vacation Rental Investment?

I work with buyers looking for vacation homes, second homes, and short-term rental investment properties throughout Ocean City, Ocean Pines, and Maryland’s surrounding coastal communities.

More Than Just Finding the Property

My experience with vacation rentals goes beyond the real estate transaction.

I own, operate, market, and manage vacation rental properties myself. That allows me to look at potential properties from two different perspectives:

The real estate investment—and the vacation rental business operating inside it.

Let’s Look at the Bigger Picture

When evaluating a potential property, we can look beyond the listing price and advertised rental history.

We can evaluate:

  • Cost of ownership
  • Rental potential
  • Comparable properties
  • Competition
  • Marketing opportunities
  • Management considerations
  • Your personal investment goals

If you’re thinking about buying an Ocean City, MD vacation rental property, let’s start by building the strategy behind the purchase.

Leave a comment

Michael Nolen
Written by Michael Nolen
Michael brings a diverse background of mortgage, loan servicing and housing experience. Michael offers his clients a variety of helpful resources, guides and services that helps make buying and selling coastal real estate in the Ocean City, Ocean Pines, and Coastal Delaware markets. Michael has over 11 years industry experience and invests and manages vacation rental properties in the Ocean City, MD area through Nolen Invest and Nolen Vacation Rentals.
Written by Author

Related posts

How Much Do Vacation Rentals in Ocean City MD Cost Homeowners?

Vacation rentals in Ocean City, MD have been a popular option for real estate investing or offsetting your cost of ownership....

Michael Nolen
By Michael Nolen - March 6, 2019
5 Best Practices for New Ocean City, MD Real Estate Buyers!

No matter if you're a new buyer in the Ocean City, MD real estate market, or you've bought or sold many properties, you always...

Michael Nolen
By Michael Nolen - October 20, 2016